Pellet vs. Wood: Which Fireplace Insert is Right for You?

Whether you have or want a wood-burning fireplace or are eager to have one installed in your home, there are a couple different types to consider. In this article, we’ll discuss two common types of fireplaces: pellet and wood burning. Both rely on the traditional method of heating and burning wood material—one using wooden pellets and the other using firewood.

While it may sound like a minor change, some significant differences between the two can ultimately impact how you use or wish to use your fireplace. However, both options are great for different reasons and will bring you the warmth and comfort you seek from your fireplace.

Differences & Similarities

Here are some of the differences to consider when choosing between a pellet and wood wood-burning insert:

Heating Output & Level

Both insert types emit a lot of warmth into your home, but there is a slight difference. A pellet insert can vary depending on the design, make and type of pellets used. Pellet fireplaces tend to be slightly more consistent with heat output, maintaining the overall temperature for extended periods. That said, firewood can bring a greater heating power, almost doubling the heat range compared to pellets. The number of firewood logs used, along with their quality and moisture, can impact this. Both options will provide you with heat, but depending on the size of your room and home will impact the overall decision.

Model & Make

Both pellet and firewood inserts can easily connect to an existing fireplace location and vent. Here at Hearth and Home Shoppe we carry Lopi’s All-Grade Pellet (AGP) insert, perfect for families of all sizes due to its low-maintenance and simple-to-use system. With a traditional wood burning insert, you have a wide range of options, including the Ambiance Flair 34, which offers a luxurious aesthetic and enhanced modernity.

Sustainability

When it comes to reducing your home’s carbon footprint, it’s essential to consider which kind of heat source will be the most sustainable. Using recycled material with pellets or natural firewood, both insert options provide a sustainable heat solution compared to electric or gas heat.

Maintenance

Wood burning fireplaces tend to produce much more ash, which can build over time. If this ash is not properly cleaned regularly, it could potentially impact the interior and cut the lifespan of the unit short. On the flip side, pellet inserts have many more electrical components, including fans, switches and motors, meaning there’s more opportunity for the unit to experience issues and require replacement. Both pellet and firewood inserts require regular maintenance and upkeep to ensure they are working properly and provide you with heat for years to come.

Price Point

Price points for both options can vary depending on the manufacturer, installation process and size. A wood-burning insert does require a chimney system. However, we do carry a variety of wood fireplace inserts that can provie you with a similar look and feel. Pellet inserts are a great option for homes with or without chimneys.

Storage Space

Wood-burning inserts require a healthy stack of firewood available to keep the fire burning. This could look like an outdoor firewood storage space or an indoor stack near your fireplace. However, if you’re working with a smaller space or simply don’t have the outdoor space for firewood, pellets come in bags easy to store and keep out of sight as needed. We are proud to carry Turnman Hardwood Pellets produced right here in Virginia, as well as Hammer’s Hot Ones from West Virginia. Both options offer a high-quality sawdust made from 100% Appalachian hardwood that help fires to start faster and last longer.

Which is Best for You?

All of our fireplace options suit different homes and families who have unique needs. While some homes are perfectly suited for a traditional wood burning fireplace, others may benefit from alternative burning fuels like pellets.

With the help of the experts at Hearth and Home Shoppe, your dream fireplace can become your reality. We would love to work with you and share our professional opinions and suggestions for your upcoming fireplace installation, renovation or makeover.

Reach out to us today to get started!